Difference Between White Ash and Green Ash (With Table)

White Ash and Green Ash are the species of the Ash tree. The Ash tree’s of the Plantae kingdom is the flowering plant of olive and lilac families. The biological name for Ash is Fraxinus. There are almost 8 billion Ash trees in the United States as per estimation. The majority of them are the white ash trees and the green ash trees.

White Ash vs Green Ash

The main difference between White ash and green ash is that the leaf scars of white ash are U-shaped while green ash is D-shaped. Also, white ash trees reach a height of 80 feet tall while green ash trees are 70 feet tall. The leaves of white ash are also longer than green ash trees. And the white ash trees are attached by longer petioles while green ash is attached by short petioles.

White Ash trees are long in height, up to 80 feet. They have shades of color in their leaves. Mostly, their leaves are lighter in color at the undersides while darker at their uppersides. The white ash trees have strength in their wood and therefore, the wood is preferred to make furniture.

Green ash trees grow up to 70 feet. It can live up to hundreds of years same as the white ash trees. Green ash trees are mostly found in floodplains and riparian areas. they adapt to the environmental conditions easily. The bark of green ash is more flakey and plate-like, with horizontal cracks.

Comparison Table Between White And Green Ash

Parâmetros de comparaçãoWhite AshGreen Ash
Nome científicoFraxinus AmericanaFraxinus Pennsylvanica
UsarThe wood is used to make baseball bats, furniture, etc.The wood is lighter but has strength so is generally used to make electric guitar’s body.
Leaf ScarsThe leaf scars are U-shaped.The leaf scars are D-shaped.
AlturaThe white trees are at least 80 feet tall.The green trees grow up to 70 feet.
SoloMostly grows in moist soil.They grow in sandy, clay soil.

What is White Ash?

White ash is a species of the ash tree. Ash is a genus of flowering plants. The scientific name of white ash is Fraxinus Americana. It is also known as American ash as it is normally found in eastern and central North America. And the species is also naturalized in Hawaii.

White ash trees are mostly found on mesonic sites in the early to mid-stages of the forest succession. The white ash is called white because the leaves are white-green from their undersides. The lower sides are light in color while the upper sides are darker. Although, some of the white ash trees have yellow color leaves which transfers to purple or red color in a later stage. The leaf scars of white ash are U-shaped.

The white ash trees reach a height of at least 80 feet tall and they grow in moist soil, and in well-drained soil which has a neutral pH acidity. The white ash tree has white strong wood which is quite dense. And therefore, it is one of the most used trees for everyday purposes like making tool handles, baseball bats, flooring, and furniture. Indeed, the wood of the white ash trees is also used to make lobster traps.

What is Green Ash?

Green Ash trees are also known as Red ash, Downy ash, Swamp Ash, and Water ash. The scientific name is Fraxinus Pennsylvanica. The green ash trees are also found in eastern and central North America. The natural habitat of the green ash trees is almost exclusively streaming sides, floodplains, riparian areas, and bottomlands. 

The wood of green ash trees is hard and has strength, indeed, they have versatile properties. They are lighter as well, still are strong, and therefore are preferred to make electric guitar bodies.  It gives a bright sound with long sustainability. Green ash trees are the most widely distributed of all the American ash tree species.

The green ash trees grow up to a height of 70 feet and they mostly grow in sandy, clay soils. They have small leaves and the leaf scars are D-shaped. Green ash trees are adaptable to environmental conditions. They can grow in full sunlight as well as partial sunlight. Their leaflets are mostly attached by short petioles and are tapered at the base.

Also, green ash is extremely popular because it can grow rapidly and have a tolerance to urban pollution. These trees are severely threatened by the emerald ash borer, an exotic beetle.

Main Differences Between White And Green Ash

  1. The white ash leaves are longer than the green ash leaves.
  2. The leaf scars are different. The leaves of white ash trees have U- shaped scars whereas the leaves of green ash trees have D-shaped scars.
  3. The white ash trees reach a height of 80 feet. On the other hand, Green ash trees reach a height of about 70 feet. That is White ash is longer in height than green ash.
  4. The white ash trees have leaves that are light in color from the underside, they are whitish-green while the upper side is dark. The green ash trees have completely green leaves.
  5. White ash trees normally grow in moist soil while green ash trees grow in clay, rocky, and sandy soils.
  6. The white ash trees need full sunlight to grow and they cannot withstand the environmental conditions while on the other hand green ash trees can withstand all environmental conditions.
  7. Leaflets of the white ash trees are attached by longer petioles while the leaflets of green ash trees are attached by short and winged petioles.

Conclusão

Both white ash and green ash trees are species of Ash tree family. And so there are similarities between the two. Although there is some difference due to which the identification of the two is possible. The white ash trees are long and are mostly grows in moist soil. They are preferred by wood makers for furniture and flooring because of their strength.

The green ash trees have small leaves and their wood is preferred to make electric guitars because their wood is a little lighter although have the same strength. The green ash trees mostly grow in sandy, rocky soil. And they can adapt to environmental conditions.

Referências

  1. https://www.fs.usda.gov/treesearch/pubs/13953
  2. https://agris.fao.org/agris-search/search.do?recordID=US8933279
  3. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s00107-008-0233-9.pdf
x
2D vs 3D