Difference Between Onions and Shallots (With Table)

Vegetables are very healthy for our body as they contain natural vitamins and minerals like potassium, vitamin A, calcium, iron, etc., that our body needs for repairing cells, managing their functions, etc. There are several types of vegetables, and each of them has its life span. Some of the vegetables can be eaten raw like tomatoes, peas, etc., but most of the vegetables need to be cooked before eating.

Onions and Shallots are the same species, but they have few differences, like they differ in shape, taste, and size. Onions come in the category of vegetables. They are of bulb shape covered with layers of skin which are peeled off during cooking or using onion in any of the dishes. While Shallots are small in size and are oblong but they can also look like Onions depending on their varieties.

Onions vs Shallots

The difference between Onions and Shallots is that Onions have a bulb shape which means they are oval from the bottom and have a knob-like structure at the top, and it has a strong cellular structure. While Shallots are subgroups of Onions that have an oblong shape and are mostly used for making sauces and decorating dishes as they are easily breakable.

Onions are oval from the bottom and are often called bulb shapes. The bulb part of the Onions is partially outside while the rest of the bulb part is dug in the sand. The top part of the Onions contains a green soft stick-like structure. That green part is called spring and is used in making salads. Sometimes when Onions are in their initial stage of growth, they are taken out, and those Onions are called spring onions.

Shallots are subsets of Onions, or we can say that they belong to the family of Onions. Shallots are smaller in size as compared to Onions and are also bitter, but after cooking, Shallots become sweet. Shallots have a good shape, that is why they are mostly preferred for making dishes or salads more attractive and also they can be easily melted into a syrup.

Comparison Table Between Onions and Shallots

Parameters of ComparisonOnions Shallots
Shape and SizeOnions are categorized as vegetables that have shapes like a bulb, they have their roots at the top which are green in color.Shallots are a type of Onion but they have oblong shapes and as compared to Onions they have a smaller size.
ColorOnions can be of different colors like pink, orange, royal purple depending on their growth period and their variety. Shallots may have a gold shade of brown or rosy red. The inner surface is as usual whitish like the onions.
TasteThe taste of the Onions depends on their growth as they can be bitter, salty, sour but mostly they taste bitter. Shallots are very bitter but when they are cooked correctly they become sweet.
UsageOnions are used in every dish also they are a necessary item in salad making and because of their antibacterial properties, their oil is used for hair growth. Mostly these are used by chefs in decorating dishes and salads because they have a good shape.
TypesThere are many types of Onions but are majorly divided into six types that are potato onions, white onions, red onions, yellow onions, shallots, and alliums. Shallots are mainly categorized into three important types and those are jersey shallots, french shallots, and Echalion shallots.

What are Onions?

Onions come in the category of Vegetables as they do not have seeds inside them, and also they grow by themselves, not with the help of flower parts of the plants like other fruits do. Onions can be eaten raw with other foods to enhance the taste buds. Also, the low-fat content in Onions helps you to lose weight and provides you with antioxidants.

Onions contain some chemical which when reacted with moisture present in the air or your eyes it produces another chemical called sulfuric acid, which causes irritation in your eyes and the resulting in tears or watery eyes. That is why Onions should be placed in chilled water before chopping as it washes out the chemical that causes watery eyes.

Some of the nutrient contents of Onions are as follows:

1. Energy = 166 KJ

2. Carbohydrates = 9.34 g

3. Fat = 0.1 g

4. Proteins = 1.1 g

5. Vitamins = Vitamin C, Riboflavin, Thiamine etc.

What are Shallots?

Shallots are also like Onions, but they have different colors, odors, shapes, and sizes. They are small Onions but with less strong cellular structure because of which they can be easily chopped. Shallots are good in taste and very rich in minerals and vitamins like vitamin a, vitamin c, and vitamin k. A fully grown Shallot has a tinge of golden brown color on its outer layer.

Shallots are planted during the springtime as they need both moistures as well as sunlight. The soil in which it is planted should be very fertile with proper moisture in it. Like Onions, they also have the green part in their top, which is edible, but they do not have a pungent smell like Onions have. They may have a more bitter taste, but it depends on their growth stage.

Some of the nutrient content of Shallots are as follows:

1. Energy = 301 KJ

2. Carbohydrates = 16.8 g

3. Fat = 0.1 g

4. Proteins = 2.5 g

5. Vitamins = Vitamin E, Vitamin K, Vitamin C etc.

Main Differences Between Onions and Shallots

  1. Onions are categorized as vegetables that have shapes like a bulb. They have their roots at the top, which are green in color. On the other hand, Shallots are a variety of Onion, but they have oblong shapes, and as compared to Onions, they have a smaller size.
  2. Shallots are mainly categorized into three important types, and those are jersey shallots, french shallots, and Echalion shallots. Whereas there are many types of Onions but are majorly divided into six types that are potato onions, white onions, red onions, yellow onions, shallots, and alliums.
  3. The taste of the Onions depends on their growth as they can be bitter, salty, sour, but mostly they taste bitter. While Shallots have a very bitter taste but when they are cooked correctly, they become sweet.
  4. Onions are used in every dish. Also, they are a necessary item in salad making, and because of their antibacterial properties, their oil is used for hair growth. Whereas Shallots are mostly used by chefs in decorating dishes and salads because they have a good shape.
  5. Both Shallots are Onions are good for health if taken in a limited quantity, but the nutritional values of Shallots are high as compared to the nutritional values of Onions. Also, Shallots contain extra Vitamins like Vitamin K and Vitamin E.

Conclusion

Onions are a very necessary item in every Indian dish as it brings an authentic taste to any dish in which it is used. Eating Onions on a high level may increase the body temperature as it contains some phytochemical which reacts with the microorganism present in our body and releases heat which causes the body temperature to rise than the average body temperature of a human body.

Onions are also called Allium Sepa. They vary in color, and the color of the Onions depends on their growth stage. There are several types of Onions. Some are sweet, and some are bitter. Shallots also belong to the species of Allium Sepa but are much smaller in size. The nutrient values of Shallots are comparatively high than the nutrient values of Onions.

References

  1. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/ptr.1222
  2. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1365-2621.1982.tb10133.x
x
2D vs 3D