SVC vs ASMX: Difference and Comparison

The field of the internet is constantly expanding. People are becoming more active on the internet in modern society.

The Internet is a virtual Home for countless information provided by millions of people.

Web services like SVC and ASMX are used to send these pieces of information from one point to another over the internet.

Key Takeaways

  1. SVC is a file extension for Windows Communication Foundation (WCF) service, while ASMX is a file extension for ASP.NET Web Services.
  2. SVC services can be self-hosted, while ASMX services require IIS to host.
  3. SVC supports multiple transport protocols, while ASMX only supports HTTP.

SVC vs ASMX

The difference between SVC and ASMX is that the SVCs is a web service that uses multiple transport protocols such as TCP/IP, HTTP, and MSMQ to exchange messages using SOAP as default, while ASMX transmits messages over HTTP only using SOAP.

Both SVC and ASMX are web services that create the pathway for data to travel between electronic mediums.

SVC vs ASMX

SVC is a Web Service and type of network connection. The expanded form of SVC is Switched Virtual Circuit.

SVC network connection used in the session of transmission and disabled when the session is completed.

Connection-oriented systems such as ATM networks and telephone networks are the devices in which the SVCs are implemented.

ASMX is also a web service like SVC. It allows sending messages or other relevant data through Simple Object Access Protocol, shortly known as SOAP.

ASMX does not require a person to know about the model of the object, programming language, or the platform being used to send or receive data.

Comparison Table

Parameters Of ComparisonSVCASMX
Full formThe full form of SVC is Switched Virtual Circuit. The full form of ASMX is the Active Server Method File.
TypeSVC as an extension is exploited by Microsoft in the Windows Communication Foundation. ASMX is a file or service that is completely based on Windows Web Server.
FormSVC is a WCF Service.ASMX is an ASP.NET service.
RequirementThe SVCs require Data Contract Serializer for their performance. ASMX requires XML Serializer for its performance.
HostingA person has multiple options of platforms to host SVCs such as Console, WAS, WinNT, etc. A person would need access to IIS to host ASMX. It is the only way to host this service.

What is SVC?

The switched virtual circuit is installed in the device based on transmission and connection. It is used to transport specific data via a packet-switched network to the destination from the source.

Also Read:  VPN vs Remote Desktop: Difference and Comparison

It converts the data in a certain way where it appears that there is a physical link between the sender and receiver. It is also known as a virtual connection.

SVCs are there to provide telecommunication services to users.

Using the packet-switched network, it makes a path for data to travel from one point to another. This transportation of data is denoted as a session, and each session requires a new path.

Multiple sessions can not be established on a similar path. SVC offers bandwidth advantages but delays a bit when establishing a connection.

SVC uses any Telco resource it can find at the time of establishing the path to be connected. This process makes SVCs cheaper than PVCs.

WAN links with misbalanced and irregular traffic of network use SVCs. SVCs are considered to be temporary connections.

It uses 4 ways in which SVC makes a connection set-up of a call, transfer of data, idle, and termination of the call.

For better understanding, a person connects to a server to download some data, and the path created by SVC gets terminated when the downloading is done.

What is ASMX?

ASMX is known to be a file whose extension is .asmx. ASMX is an ASP.NET file that is also considered to be a Web Service file.

This file is used to establish a communication path between two nodes using the Internet and SOAP (Simple Object Access Protocol). ASMX is a service that is based on Windows Web Server.

It is deployed in the system to acquire the income request to connect and send the required response. There is another similar service like ASMX, which is known as ASPX.

Also Read:  Star vs Ring Topology: Difference and Comparison

But the major difference between the two is that users have to open a separate window to run ASPX while the Web Service ASMX runs in the background.

Its service includes retrieving the data, sending the data in the required format, connecting to the database, etc.

The ASMX file can be opened in applications such as text editors or Microsoft Visual Studio because these files are written in plain-text form.

When a response comes in the form of SOAP XML by an ASMX file, it includes four elements: Envelope, Header, Body, and Fault.

Nowadays, .NET languages such as Visual Basics, Jscript, and C# are being used to write ASMX files.

Main Differences Between SVC and ASMX

  1. SVCs are considered to be WCF Services. On the other hand, ASMX is considered to be an ASP.NET service.
  2. SVCs have multiple options for hosting, while ASMX can be hosted on IIS (Internet Information Server) only.
  3. The SVCs tend to use a Data Contract Serializer to be performed. On the other hand, ASMX needs an XML Serializer.
  4. The SVC extension is used in Microsoft applications, while ASMX is based on Windows Web Server for several objectives.
  5. SVC stands for switched virtual circuit. On the other hand, ASMX stands for Active Server Method File
References
  1. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/4317642/

Last Updated : 13 July, 2023

dot 1
One request?

I’ve put so much effort writing this blog post to provide value to you. It’ll be very helpful for me, if you consider sharing it on social media or with your friends/family. SHARING IS ♥️

11 thoughts on “SVC vs ASMX: Difference and Comparison”

  1. The content is very detailed and needed in the current times. It provides great insight into the field of web services. The comparison table is especially helpful.

    Reply
  2. This article fails to address some key differences between SVC and ASMX. I expected more in-depth information, and that was not delivered.

    Reply
    • I understand your point, but remember that not all articles can cater to every reader’s expectations. The available information here is valuable nonetheless.

      Reply
    • I disagree, I think the article did a great job of outlining the important differences. You might want to re-read it.

      Reply
  3. The content of the article is quite engaging and well-written. It definitely contributes to the understanding of SVC and ASMX.

    Reply
  4. Very informative article, it provides a clear explanation about SVC and ASMX. It is a great resource for anyone looking to understand the difference between these two web services.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Want to save this article for later? Click the heart in the bottom right corner to save to your own articles box!