Deodorant is a product that is applied to the body to prevent it from the bad smell or odour caused by bacteria. Deodorants can be further divided into different categories called antiperspirants.
Antiperspirants prevent sweating in the body by blocking sweat glands. It is applied to the broader body areas where sweat is unwanted.
Some of them do not block sweat glands but prevent bacterial action. Mum, the first commercial Deodorant, came in 1888, developed and patented by Edna Murphey. There are various types of deodorants. Gel and Solid Deodorant are one of them.
Key Takeaways
- Gel deodorants are clear, fast-drying, and less likely to leave residue on clothes.
- Solid deodorants come in stick form, are opaque, and provide a stronger barrier against sweat.
- Gel deodorants are better for quick-drying and minimal residue, while solid deodorants offer stronger protection against sweat.
Gel vs Solid Deodorant
Gel deodorant is a liquid or semi-liquid substance applied to the skin using an applicator, such as a roll-on ball or a pump. The gel dries quickly and leaves a cooling sensation on the skin. Solid Deodorant is a waxy substance that is applied to the skin by rubbing it onto the skin’s surface. Solid deodorants contain a combination of antiperspirant and deodorant ingredients.
Gel Deodorant has very similar packaging to solid Deodorant. Whenever the bottle is twisted, gel oozes out of it. Gel deodorant needs to be dried first after applying. Once it gets dried, it feels invisible.
One of the most important things to remember before applying gel deodorant is that after taking a shower, it should be applied, let dry, and then put on the clothes.
Usually, Gel Deodorants are environmentally friendly. It contains no harmful chemicals. It doesn’t leave stains on the clothes.
Solid Deodorants, also called Stick deodorants or cream perfumes, come in the form of solid, unlike liquid deodorants. Solid deodorants get their base from a wax that is melted initially to give it a texture of a cream.
Once the wax gets melted, various types of scents are added to it. Solid Deodorants are very portable and easy to carry. It can be used either by rubbing or using cotton against the skin.
Sometimes, solid deodorants take more time to come out than Gel deodorants.
Comparison Table
| Parameters of Comparison | Gel Deodorant | Solid Deodorant |
|---|---|---|
| Form | Liquid, thick, clear gel | Creamy, wavy, solid |
| Ingredients | Aluminium chlorohydrate, aluminium sulfate, aluminium zirconium aluminium chloride, and complexes. | Tetrachlorohydrex GLY (in solids), Aluminum chlorohydrate and aluminium zirconium. |
| Application | Discreet and takes time to dry. | Easy to use & apply, dries quickly |
| Stain | Leave stains and spots. | Not travel-friendly. |
| Portability | Portable and Travel friendly | Portable and Travel friendly |
What is Gel Deodorant?
Gel Deodorant is made up of small rocks or crystals. It comes in a plastic container. Because of the presence of crystals, gel deodorants are more acidic.
Like the other deodorants, thedon’t’t remove the sweating process but help to remove the odour from the armpits. The gel in Gel deodorants acts as a carrier. It makes our underarms fresh and dry.
Gel Deodorants were first patented in the 1950s. Earlier, they contain sodium stearate soap gels. But over the years, Gel deodorants have been developed. Now the gel in it is more stable. Now Gel deodorants also come in the form of gel sticks.
Since its invention, it has become one of the iconic personal products of fragrance and essential oil to remove the body’s odour. It has the power to stay on the body for a longer time.
It is thick and clear. But it is not easy to carry them. Once applied, it needs some time to be dried. But after it is dried, it feels like it becomes invisible. It can melt if there is a higher temperature.
Gel deodorants are very safe deodorants. Because it contains less harmful chemical substances, they do not leave stains or marks on the clothes.
What is Solid Deodorant?
Solid Deodorants are meant to kill body odour. But just like gel deodorants, they also cannot completely stop the sweat glands from sweating.
Solid Deodorants act as antiperspirants that reduce the sweat on the human skin, kill the bacteria and thus eliminate the odour in the armpits. Solid Deodorants are also called stick Deodorants.
They come in solid form with a twisted knob at the bottom in a small plastic container. When opened, a solid stick can be applied to the armpit to make it dry and clear.
Solid Deodorants get dried very quickly. It is straightforward to use and apply. However, it can cause skin irritation to those with an allergy. They can leave stains and marks on the clothes, especially if you wear dark-coloured garments.
They are very portable and easy to carry. They are Travel friendly. Ingredients of Solid Deodorants majorly consist of aerosol and some solidifying agents.
It can be reapplied many times in a day. Solid Deodorants have become a default option for many people. They contain fewer chemicals or are chemical-free.
The texture of Solid Deodorants is very creamy, filmy, and wavy, just like soap. People having sensitive skin may not like it because of its moist texture.
Main Differences Between Gel and Solid Deodorant
- Gel Deodorants have liquid or transparent gel form. They are thick and clear. Solid Deodorants are a creamy and wavy texture. It is in solid form.
- Ingredients of Gel Deodorant include Aluminium chlorohydrate, aluminium sulfate, aluminium zirconium aluminium chloride, and complexes. Ingredients of Solid Deodorant include Tetrachlorohydrex GLY (in solids), Aluminum chlorohydrate and aluminium zirconium.
- Gel deodorants are very discreet and take time to dry. Solid Deodorants are Easy to use & apply and dry quickly.
- Gel deodoranDoesn’t’t leave stains and marks on clothes. Solid Deodorant Leaves stains and marks on clothes.
- Gel deodorants are not travel-friendly and can melt in higher temperatures. Solid Deodorants are portable and travel-friendly.
Last Updated : 03 July, 2023
I’ve put so much effort writing this blog post to provide value to you. It’ll be very helpful for me, if you consider sharing it on social media or with your friends/family. SHARING IS ♥️
Piyush Yadav has spent the past 25 years working as a physicist in the local community. He is a physicist passionate about making science more accessible to our readers. He holds a BSc in Natural Sciences and Post Graduate Diploma in Environmental Science. You can read more about him on his bio page.
It’s great to see a comprehensive comparison between these two types of deodorants. Engaging and well-researched.
Who knew deodorants could be so fascinating? The development of gel deodorants in particular is quite an interesting evolution.
Absolutely! This article provides valuable insights into the history and composition of deodorants.
Indeed, the scientific and practical aspects of deodorants make for an intriguing read.
Solid deodorants are clearly the superior choice. Their convenience and portability outweigh the benefits of gel deodorants.
You make a compelling argument, but I believe gel deodorants have their own merits that appeal to different consumers.
This article successfully expounds on the differences between gel and solid deodorant. The comparison table is a welcome addition.
I was not aware of the different types of deodorants and their unique qualities. Very informative article.
The comparison between gel and solid deodorant is quite useful. However, people may have different preferences based on personal requirements, making it hard to say one is better than the other.
I disagree. Solid deodorant may be more popular due to its ease of use and application.