Kheera vs Kakdi – Difference Between Kheera and Kakdi

Since the discovery of the cultivation of fruits and vegetables in the Stone Age, every generation uses different names to specify a particular vegetable. But for someone not so keen on cooking, these names can appear to be confusing. For instance, Kheera and Kakdi are vegetables that are often confused. These names are actively used in the Hindi or Marathi language we often consider them to be the same, but they are different.   

Kheera vs Kakdi  

The main difference between Kheera and Kakdi is that Kheera is popularly known as Cucumber and is a plant that gives rise to a cylindrical vegetable. Cucumber is a creeping vine. On the other hand, Kakdi is popularly known as Armenian Cucumber, which belongs to the family of melons. Kakdi is a long, slender fruit that appears strikingly similar to Cucumber, yet is different in its way.   

Kheera vs Kakdi

Kheera or Cucumber is an annual plant that originated in India as a creeping vine, a plant that starts growing from the ground and further grows with the help of support. A raw cucumber has many nutritional benefits, like vitamin K and an almost negligible amount of fat. Cucumber slightly tastes bitter due to Cucurbitacin.  

On the other hand, we include Kakdi or Armenian Cucumber in the classification of a muskmelon. Due to its appearance (long, tapering ends), we also refer it to as snake melon, snake cucumber. It is often confused with snake gourd, but both differ in texture, taste, etc. We can grow it on a trellis or ground. The plant requires a lot of water to grow. 

Comparison Table Between Kheera and Kakdi  

Parameters of Comparison    Kheera   Kakdi    
Popular Name    Cucumber   Armenian Cucumber    
Classified under    Cylindrical Fruits     Melons or Muskmelons  
Height Range    20-24 Inches    12-15 Inches    
Scientific Name    Cucumis sativus  Cucumis melo var. flexuosus    
Used as    Vegetable (Salads)  Armenian Cucumber Pickles  

What is Kheera?  

Aforementioned, Kheera (also called a cucumber) belongs to the family of Cucurbitaceae. It is a creeper plant that gives rise to a cylindrical fruit that is used as a vegetable. Cucumber originated in India. In the Hindi language, we refer to it as Kheera. It is an annual plant and has several varieties grown currently.  

Cucumber or Kheera originated in India about 3000 years ago. Kheera and other varieties of cucumber were found in the Indian Subcontinent. It was introduced to the world through the Europeans. Thus, it became a staple worldwide. Presently, all countries worldwide grow many varieties of cucumber.   

Being a creeper, the Cucumber plant can even grow in a soilless medium with enough water. Owing to the flexibility concerning its cultivation, currently, there are numerous types of cucumbers grown globally, for instance, the Slicing, Gherkins, Pickling, and Seedless varieties.   

Any cucumber can be used for preparing pickles, but we grow specific cucumbers for it, known as the Pickling Cucumbers or Picklers. These cucumbers are comparatively short, with enough flesh, lacks voids in the flesh, and are slightly irregular. The color of the cucumber can vary from green to pale yellow.   

Along with this, Slicers and Seedless cucumbers are vital varieties. Slicers are long, uniform cucumbers that are devoured directly. Seedless cucumbers are sweeter, thin-skinned, and are often popular in the markets.   

What is Kakdi?  

As mentioned above, Kakdi or Armenian Cucumber is a type of muskmelon that is strikingly similar to cucumbers, yet differs in taste, texture, shape, etc. Kakdi is highly nutritious and is often consumed raw or in salads. It does not require processing like seedling or peeling. It can be cut into slices and consumed. The color of an Armenian Cucumber ranges from yellow-green to dark green.   

The shape of a cucumber is curvy and not straight, like other cucumbers. These types of cucumbers are soft-skinned with smooth flesh that can be used for preparing pickles. Pickled Armenian Cucumbers are popular in the Middle Eastern Market. They refer to it as Pickled Wild Cucumbers.   

We can include Kakdi plants in the sunny plant’s classification. They require high-temperature 50-60 degrees (heat-tolerant) to grow and ripe well. Since India is a tropical country, India is one of the top producers of Armenian Cucumbers. Also, this plant requires a sufficient amount of water to grow.   

Best flavored Armenian Cucumbers grow up to 15-18 inches. But owing to the conditions they are cultivated in; they can grow up to 36 inches. We can include them in the creeper plants that can grow well in-ground or on a trellis. These plants are only specific with the amount of sunlight and water, as they need constant water while fruiting.  

Taste-wise, Kakdi is never bitter, thus requires no processing. Along with this name, Kakdi is also called yard-long cucumber, snake cucumber; the designation varies with every country.   

Main Differences Between Kheera and Kakdi  

  1. Kheera is popularly known as Cucumber, whereas Kakdi is known as Armenian Cucumber.  
  2. We can classify Kheera as a cylindrical fruit, while we often classify Kakdi as a sub-category of muskmelon.   
  3. The scientific name of Kheera is Cucumis sativus, whereas the scientific name of Kakdi is Cucumis melo var. Flexuosus.  
  4. The average height of Kheera is 24 Inches whereas the height of a Kakdi can range from 15 to 36 inches.   
  5. Kheera can grow even in low-water conditions, whereas Kakdi requires a sufficient amount of water to grow.   
  6. Kheera should be peeled and is processed to remove the bitterness, whereas we can consume Kakdi directly.   
Difference Between Kheera and Kakdi

Conclusion  

From the above points, it is evident that even though Kheera and Kakdi belong to the same family of Cucurbitaceae, they differ in taste, texture, smell, skin, color, etc. Even though Kakdis appear similar to Kheeras from the inside, one can perceive the difference between them by tasting them.   

We use both Kheera and Kakdi in salads and pickles. Some may even consume them directly as fruits; Kheera needs to be processed due to its bitter taste, while Kakdi can be directly consumed. In many countries, Armenian Cucumbers are famous because of the Pickles sold. Nowadays, hybrid varieties of both these vegetables are cultivated to improve their nutritional value. These vegetables are prominent in highly populated nations like China and India, as they are equally nutritious and beneficial.   

References 

  1. https://apply.jar.punjab.gov.pk/upload/1523508270_130_3._JAR_1173.pdf 
  2. https://growables.com/informationVeg/documents/CucumberArmenian.pdf 
Search for "Ask Any Difference" on Google. Rate this post!(Total: 0 votes,average: 0 votes)