RSTP vs PVST: Difference and Comparison

The multicast routing protocol has two versions: RSTP and PVST. Computers are the only ones that use the spanning-tree method.

It guarantees a loop-free architecture and avoids bridge loops and the resulting broadcasting radiation as a protocol stack.

In the event of an operational link breakdown, the protocol’s architecture provides spare connections as an automated backup.

Hence, the two versions are sometimes difficult to bifurcate. This article will help you understand the significance and functioning of RSTP and PVST based on their differences and mechanical assembly.

Key Takeaways

  1. Rapid Spanning Tree Protocol (RSTP) provides faster convergence than Per-VLAN Spanning Tree (PVST) in bridged networks.
  2. RSTP operates per instance, while PVST creates a separate spanning tree for each VLAN.
  3. PVST offers granular control over VLAN traffic, whereas RSTP simplifies network management with fewer instances.

RSTP vs PVST

RSTP provides faster convergence times, which means that network devices can recover more quickly from topology changes such as link failures or additions. PVST provides better bandwidth utilization and redundancy for each VLAN, as the failure of a single switch or link will only affect the VLANs that are associated with it.

RSTP vs PVST

RSTP stands for Rapid Spanning Tree Protocol and is a network management protocol for Ethernet connections that assures a loop-free architecture.

Implementing redundant networking in important systems like Energy, Aviation, or Factory Automation is common nowadays. The IEEE 802.1Q-2014 standard includes this interface.

IEEE 802.1D is the specification for RSTP. STP produces a tree structure within a grid range of interconnected layer-2 bridges. Ethernet exchanges are commonly used as layer-2 gateways.

PVST, on the other hand, stands for Per VLAN Spanning Tree and is a Cisco closed source that dates back to the company’s inception.

It maintains a binary tree instance for each unique VLAN established in the system. It basically affects each VLAN separately.

It employs Cisco’s patented ISL trunking technology and is built on the 802.1D specification.

Also Read:  Cisco Tetration vs Stealthwatch: Difference and Comparison

Comparison Table

Parameters of ComparisonRSTPPVST
MeaningRSTP is a loop-free network protocol for Ethernet networks.PVST is a kind of solitary Spanning Tree Network. It maintains a distinct Spanning Tree Protocol (STP) instance for each unique VLAN.
Full FormRapid Spanning Tree Protocol.Per-VLAN Spanning Tree
Proprietary ofThe IEEE 802.1Q-2014 standard includes this interface to run RSTP.PVST is only compatible with Cisco protocols. It itself is proprietary of Cisco.
Used inLAN (Local Area Network)VLAN (Virtual Local Area Network)
ExtensionsNo extensions are available.Extensions of Cisco are available for VLANs with PVST.

What is RSTP?

Rapid Spanning Tree Protocol is the abbreviation of RSTP, a loop-free network protocol for Ethernet networks.

Rapid Spanning Tree Protocol (RSTP) enables much quicker spanning-tree resolution following a topology change when compared to PVST, which is custom owned by Cisco.

The IEEE 802.1Q-2014 standard includes this interface. When infrastructure changes take place, RSTP delivers speedup over 802.1D STP.

RSTP describes five port roles: root, authorized, auxiliary, backup, and deactivated, as well as three-port states: discarding, understanding, and pushing.

IEEE 802.1D is the guideline for RSTP. STP produces a tree structure within a mesh range of interconnected layer-2 bridges.

Ethernet adapters are commonly used as layer-2 gateways. STP disables non-spanning tree connections, leaving just one active channel between any two nodes in the network.

RSTP also provides for the inclusion of spare and/or high availability in a network architecture. In the event that an active connection breaks, these provide automated backup pathways.

These spare links are incorporated without the risk of bridge cycles or the requirement for periodic enabling/disabling of something like the fallback links.

What is PVST?

Spanning Tree Protocol (STP) is a kind of singularly mounted Spanning Tree Network which is dealt with when running the PVST compatibility with various VLANs.

In large switched Frequent Spanning Tree (CST) networks, delays in receiving BPDUs are conventional. The time it takes to receive BPDUs might cause issues such as cluster formation.

Also Read:  Cyber vs Network Security: Difference and Comparison

PVST (Per-VLAN Spanning Tree) is a solution to these issues. Developed by Cisco Path Selection Protocol, Per-VLAN Spanning Tree (PVST) maintains a distinct instance of Spanning Tree Protocol (STP) for each unique VLAN.

Each VLAN may be set up individually and function better with a change slightly of Spanning Tree Protocol (STP).

They can’t be utilized on most 3rd party routers since they’re Cisco’s patented implementation of the Spanning Tree Protocol.

PVST+ is just another Cisco interface (Per-VLAN Spanning Tree Plus). PVST only operates with Cisco’s proprietary VLAN encoding technology, ISL.

This one is due to the inherent Path selection ID in ISL, which is the based standardized protocol IP on ISL-capable Cisco switches.

This Cisco device can communicate with other PVST devices’ bridging trees but never with IEEE 802.1Q computers. All of the ports on an IEEE 802.1Q device run on a single tree structure, and the PVST is fully compatible with Cisco-patented devices only.

Main Differences Between RSTP and PVST

  1. RSTP is compatible with all IEEE 802.1 router networks, whereas PVST is only compatible with Cisco protocols.
  2. RSTP stands for Rapid Spanning Tree Protocol, whereas PVST stands for Per-VLAN Spanning Tree.
  3. The RSTP is an enhancement on the multicast routing protocol, and it is an IEEE standard spanning tree, whereas the PVST is a Cisco patented spanning tree protocol.
  4. RSTP does not have any extensions, whereas Cisco aids PVST to be compatible with other spanning tree setups.
  5. RSTP is mostly used in LANs, whereas PVSTs are used in VLANs, i.e. Virtual Local Area Networks.
References
  1. https://docs.commscope.com/bundle/fastiron-08090-l2guide/page/GUID-F9905D20-F2BB-4286-B606-49BC36596CF1.html
  2. https://www.accuenergy.com/support/reference-directory/rapid-spanning-tree-protocol-rstp/

Last Updated : 13 July, 2023

dot 1
One request?

I’ve put so much effort writing this blog post to provide value to you. It’ll be very helpful for me, if you consider sharing it on social media or with your friends/family. SHARING IS ♥️

12 thoughts on “RSTP vs PVST: Difference and Comparison”

  1. The comparisons and definitions of RSTP and PVST in this article are highly educational. I learned a lot from reading this.

    Reply
  2. This article does a great job of outlining the differences and use cases of RSTP and PVST. Very helpful information for network administrators.

    Reply
  3. This article delivers a thorough analysis of RSTP and PVST, offering valuable insights into their functionality and implementation.

    Reply
    • I wholeheartedly agree. The article provides an in-depth exploration of the multicast routing protocols which is very beneficial.

      Reply
  4. The breakdown of RSTP and PVST in this article is quite comprehensive. It serves as a valuable resource for network professionals and enthusiasts.

    Reply
  5. The technical details and comparisons between RSTP and PVST are well-presented. It’s very helpful for understanding the significance of these protocols in network management.

    Reply
  6. The detailed comparison of RSTP and PVST is very helpful. It’s a well-structured and informative article.

    Reply
  7. This article provides a clear and concise explanation of the differences between RSTP and PVST. I appreciate the thorough analysis of the protocols.

    Reply
  8. Great article. I’ve been looking for detailed information on RSTP and PVST and this article provides a comprehensive comparison between the two. Well done!

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Want to save this article for later? Click the heart in the bottom right corner to save to your own articles box!