Amish vs Mennonite: Difference and Comparison

Amish: Traditionalist Anabaptists who live in tightly-knit communities, eschewing modern technology. Mennonite: Descendants of the Anabaptist movement, varying from conservative to liberal in beliefs and practices, embracing modernity while maintaining core values.

Key Takeaways

  1. Both Amish and Mennonite are Christian denominations that originated in Europe.
  2. The Amish are a more conservative sect that emphasizes separation from modern society and the use of technology.
  3. The Mennonites are a more progressive sect emphasizing engagement with contemporary culture and social justice.

Difference Between Amish and Mennonite

Amish group was founded by Jakob Ammann, who believed that any sin needs severe punishment. Many people got attracted to this concept by Jacob Amann and started following it. In comparison, another group named Mennonites followed the same old peaceful practices of Anabaptists.

Amish vs Mennonite
/10

Religion Quiz

Test your knowledge about topics related to religion

1 / 10

The first day of Lent is

2 / 10

What was the name of the person who first started spreading Christianity around the Roman empire?

3 / 10

What is the story: 'Ramayana' about?

4 / 10

What is the main message of the book of Proverbs in the Old Testament?

5 / 10

Who wrote the four Gospels in the New Testament (Matthew, Mark, Luke, John)?

6 / 10

What is the Four Noble Truths in Buddhism?

7 / 10

Who wrote the first five books of the Bible, also known as the Pentateuch?

8 / 10

What is the main belief of Sikhism?

9 / 10

What is the main text of Sikhism?

10 / 10

In what year did Martin Luther post his 95 Theses, starting the Protestant Reformation?

Your score is

0%

Amish follow the traditional and stringent practices of Anabaptists. They don’t get involved with other people worldwide and don’t believe in technology adoption.

They dress in very plain traditional clothes and travel in buggies or scooters.

Mennonites are known as a non-violent and flexible group of Anabaptists. They embrace and adopt the latest technology in their daily life. They are involved more in missionary work to help deprived people and spread their beliefs & faith across the world.


 

Comparison Table

FeatureAmishMennonite
OriginAnabaptist movement in Switzerland and Germany (16th century)Split from Amish in the late 17th century
Religious beliefsSimilar core Anabaptist beliefs (adult baptism, separation of church and state, non-resistance), but Amish interpretations are stricterMore diverse range of interpretations and practices within Mennonite groups
Technology and modernityStrict rejection of most modern technology (electricity, cars, phones, etc.) and live a simple, traditional lifestyleVarying degrees of openness to technology and modern conveniences, with some groups adhering to simpler lifestyles and others integrating more modern elements
ClothingPlain and modest clothing in specific styles and colorsPlain dress is encouraged, but styles and colors may vary widely between groups
Community and social interactionClose-knit, insular communities with limited interaction with the outside worldMore integrated into wider society, with varying degrees of interaction depending on the group
EducationLimited formal education, focus on practical skills and religious instructionVaries widely, with some groups encouraging higher education and others focusing on vocational training
Missionary workLess emphasis on missionary work, focus on maintaining their own communitiesMore active in missionary work and outreach efforts
Church servicesHeld in homes or barns, simple and traditionalHeld in church buildings, with varying degrees of formality depending on the group
Examples of groupsOld Order Amish, Swartzentruber AmishLancaster Mennonite Conference, Mennonite Church USA

 

What is Amish?

Amish belong to the North American Christian group, formerly belonged to the Anabaptists group. Jakob Ammann founded the Amish group in the late 17th century.

Jakob Ammann was a reluctant and robust believer of ex-communication, i.e., if anybody doesn’t follow the rules of religion and lies, he/she will be shunned from the community.

He was a non-resistance believer but sturdily favoured the social shunning of people involved in any wrongdoings.

Amish people live in close-knit communities that are separated from the mainstream world. They follow very stringent customs, life, and behaviour rules that are not explicitly written but exist and are known as Ordnung.

German, or the regular dialect of German or Pennsylvania Dutch, is the language used by Amish for communication at church and English in daily life at home.

Amish people do Church services at home within the closed community on a rotational basis. They wear very plain clothes that are known as a nonconformist lifestyle.

Amish man has full beard without moustaches, and women wear solid-colour dresses without jewellery.

Amish group strictly prohibits the use of technology of any kind. And the mode of transportation is a horse-driven vehicle or scooter.

Beliefs and Practices

Religious Beliefs

The Amish are a Christian group known for their traditional practices. They believe in the Holy Trinity, practice adult baptism, and interpret the Bible literally. They embrace nonresistance and pacifism, separate themselves from mainstream society, and prioritize community and family. Humility and modesty are central to their lifestyle.

Lifestyle and Community

The Amish lead a simple lifestyle focused on community and traditional values. They dress plainly, limit technology use, and prioritize agriculture. They support each other through mutual aid, follow unwritten guidelines called the Ordnung, and worship in homes or church buildings. Amish children attend Amish schools, and the value of humility, contentment, and submission to God’s will is central to their way of life.

Technology and Modernization

The Amish intentionally limit technology use to maintain a traditional and simple lifestyle. They avoid modern conveniences like electricity, cars, and the internet. Each community decides on the level of technology adoption, prioritizing traditional methods and evaluating potential impacts on their values and unity. They may occasionally outsource tasks requiring modern equipment. Media exposure is also limited due to concerns about its influence.

Amish Today

Population and Distribution

The Amish population is around 350,000 worldwide. They are concentrated in North America, primarily in the United States and Canada. Amish communities, known as settlements, are found in rural areas and vary in size. The Amish prefer limited interaction with the outside world and maintain their distinct way of life within their self-contained communities.

Challenges and Controversies

The Amish face challenges in education, healthcare, technology, social integration, gender roles, genetic disorders, and the practice of ex-communication. Their approach to education clashes with compulsory schooling laws. Reliance on natural remedies poses challenges in accessing modern medical treatments. Avoidance of technology leads to tensions with government regulations.

Maintaining a separate way of life creates challenges in interacting with broader society. Traditional gender roles draw criticism regarding women’s rights. Limited gene pool results in a higher prevalence of genetic disorders. Excommunication and shunning, while preserving faith and values, create emotional and social challenges.

Tourism and Commercialization

Amish communities have become tourist attractions, with guided tours offering visitors a glimpse into their traditional lifestyle. Amish-made products like furniture and quilts have gained recognition, leading to commercialization. However, the commercialization of Amish culture raises ethical concerns about respecting their privacy and traditions.

Challenges arise from increased tourism, including disruptions to the Amish way of life and tensions between the community and visitors. The presence of tourism and commercialization may also introduce outside influences that challenge traditional Amish values. Striking a balance between sharing Amish culture and respecting their desire for privacy is an ongoing debate. Sensitivity and respect are crucial when engaging in Amish tourism, considering the potential impacts on their community and values.

amish
 

What is Mennonite?

Mennonites’ group resulted from the 16th-century reformation movement that came from Anabaptists. It was named after Frisian Menno Simons, a Dutch priest who tried to institutionalize the workings of moderate Anabaptist leaders.

Mennonites’ belief and faith systems revolve around human betterment, and they try to help the poor of any section. They live commonly among the average population, not in close-knit communities.

They believe in belongingness and are known as peacemakers. They used German in the late 16th century but later adopted English as their common communication language at home and at Church.

Mennonites give more emphasis on one’s pacifism and conscience to worship God. They believe religion and the rest world should not be mixed and should be followed separately.

They follow rigorous religious practices and discipline in their group. They live a simple life with simple clothing but evolve with time and are involved in educational, social, and economic advancements.

Mennonites moderately use modern technology in day-to-day life. And also use automobiles for transportation.

Mennonite Lifestyle

Community

The Mennonite community is a Christian denomination known for its emphasis on peace, simplicity, and community living. They follow the teachings of Jesus Christ and value pacifism, nonviolence, and social justice. Mennonites are part of the Anabaptist tradition and believe in adult baptism, voluntary church membership, and the separation of church and state.

Community living is central to their way of life, residing in close-knit, intentional communities. Mennonites engage in service and missions, providing aid and assistance locally and globally. Education is highly valued, with a focus on providing quality education to their children. Mennonites have a global presence, with communities found worldwide and contributions made to peacebuilding and humanitarian efforts. It’s important to acknowledge that Mennonite practices and beliefs can vary among different groups and regions.

Education

Mennonites highly value education and prioritize providing quality education to their children. Reflecting their beliefs and values, Mennonite schools integrate academic subjects with Mennonite teachings. These faith-based schools aim to instil Christian principles, such as peace, service, and social justice while fostering spiritual growth and community. Mennonite education takes a holistic approach, nurturing intellectual development, character formation, moral values, and practical life skills.

Teacher-student relationships emphasize personalized attention, mentorship, and a supportive learning environment. Mennonite students pursue higher education in various fields, with some communities having their colleges and universities. Lifelong learning is encouraged, as education is an ongoing process for personal growth and intellectual curiosity. It’s important to note that Mennonite education practices may vary among communities and regions, reflecting the diversity within the Mennonite denomination.

Work and Careers

Mennonites engage in diverse work and careers that reflect their skills and interests. Many Mennonites are involved in agriculture, practising sustainable farming and animal husbandry. They excel in skilled trades like woodworking, carpentry, and blacksmithing, producing handcrafted furniture and artisanal products. Mennonites value education, leading to careers in teaching at both Mennonite and public schools.

Their commitment to service extends to healthcare and social services, with Mennonites working as doctors, nurses, therapists, and volunteers. Business and entrepreneurship are common paths, emphasizing ethical practices and community well-being. Mennonites actively participate in mission work, non-profit organizations, and professional careers spanning law, engineering, finance, technology, and the arts. Personal interests, community traditions, and values influence their work choices. Service, stewardship, and community welfare are central to Mennonite work ethics.

Mennonite Culture

Music and Art

Music and art are important in the Mennonite community, enriching worship, cultural expression, and community life. Mennonite music is characterized by congregational singing, with distinctive features of cappella hymns and four-part harmony. Sacred and secular choral music is embraced and performed by Mennonite choirs. Instrumental music, including the piano, organ, violin, and guitar, accompanies worship and is featured in music ensembles.

Mennonite cultural heritage is preserved through folk music, traditional songs, and instruments like the accordion and fiddle. Visual arts encompass painting, sculpture, ceramics, and textile arts, reflecting Mennonite beliefs, traditions, and the natural world. Mennonite women are renowned for their quilting and needlework skills, producing intricate and vibrant quilts. Drama and theatre productions and cultural festivals celebrate Mennonite creativity and heritage. Music and art serve as avenues for worship, artistic expression, storytelling, and community engagement within the Mennonite community.

Food and Cuisine

Mennonite cuisine has a rich culinary heritage rooted in traditional recipes and a commitment to wholesome, hearty dishes. Emphasizing a farm-to-table approach, Mennonites prioritize fresh, locally sourced ingredients, grown on their farms. Comfort foods like homemade bread, soups, stews, casseroles, and meat-based dishes are staples in Mennonite cooking. Preservation techniques such as canning, pickling, and jam-making allow Mennonites to enjoy the flavours of summer year-round.

Mennonite baking is highly regarded, with homemade bread, pies, cakes, cookies, and pastries showcasing their culinary skills. Cultural influences from regions where Mennonites have settled contribute to variations in their cuisine, such as Pennsylvania Dutch and German influences. Community meals and gatherings foster fellowship, community, and hospitality. Mennonites also consider ethical considerations in their food choices, prioritizing sustainability, organic ingredients, and vegetarian options. Mennonite food reflects their heritage, values, and commitment to simple, homemade, and nourishing meals.

Traditions and Celebrations

Mennonites have a rich tapestry of traditions and celebrations that reflect their faith, culture, and community bonds. They gather for worship services, including congregational singing, prayers, and sermons. Community meals, such as potluck dinners and church suppers, foster fellowship and a sense of belonging. Mennonites are committed to peace and justice, engaging in nonviolent activism and humanitarian efforts. They honour their Anabaptist heritage through historical commemorations and educational programs.

Family reunions and genealogical research strengthen family connections and preserve ancestral knowledge. Weddings and funerals are significant community milestones. Harvest festivals and seasonal celebrations mark the abundance of the land. Christmas and Easter hold religious significance, observed through worship services, music performances, and family gatherings. Mennonite traditions and celebrations strengthen community bonds, deepen faith, honour heritage, and promote peace, justice, and family values, contributing to a strong sense of identity within the Mennonite community.

mennonite

Main Differences Between Amish and Mennonite

  • Technology Usage:
    • Amish: Generally reject modern technology, including electricity and automobiles.
    • Mennonite: Embrace a wider range of technology, with varying degrees of acceptance among different groups.
  • Lifestyle and Dress:
    • Amish: Known for distinctive plain dress and a focus on agrarian living in close-knit, rural communities.
    • Mennonite: Dress and lifestyle can vary greatly, ranging from traditional to more modern, and may include involvement in urban or suburban settings.
  • Church Structure:
    • Amish: Typically organize worship in private homes or simple meetinghouses, with a strong emphasis on community.
    • Mennonite: Often have formal church buildings and a more diverse range of worship styles and structures.
  • Education:
    • Amish: Typically limit formal education to eighth grade and emphasize practical skills and community values.
    • Mennonite: Often prioritize education and may have a broader range of educational opportunities, including higher education.
  • Approach to Evangelism and Mission:
    • Amish: Generally focus on maintaining their distinct way of life rather than actively seeking converts.
    • Mennonite: Often engage in evangelism and may have missions both domestically and internationally, with a focus on peace and social justice issues.
Difference Between Amish and Mennonite
References
  1. https://www.etown.edu/centers/young-center/files/hmorton-references/Pediatric%20Medicine%20and%20Genetics%202003.pdf
  2. https://repository.lboro.ac.uk/articles/Physical_activity_profile_of_old_order_Amish_Mennonite_and_contemporary_children/9626393/files/17275031.pdf

Last Updated : 10 February, 2024

dot 1
One request?

I’ve put so much effort writing this blog post to provide value to you. It’ll be very helpful for me, if you consider sharing it on social media or with your friends/family. SHARING IS ♥️

22 thoughts on “Amish vs Mennonite: Difference and Comparison”

  1. The strict lifestyle of the Amish and the more flexible approach of the Mennonites provide an interesting contrast. It’s a testament to the diversity within Christianity.

    1. Avatar of Katie Bennett
      Katie Bennett

      Yes, it’s a reminder that there’s no one-size-fits-all approach to faith, and diversity of practice is a strength.

  2. It’s fascinating to see the differences in beliefs and practices between the Amish and the Mennonites. Their dedication to their respective lifestyles is truly admirable.

  3. The strict adherence to traditional values by the Amish and the progressive approach of the Mennonites showcase the diverse expressions of Christianity. It’s a testament to the richness of religious traditions.

    1. Absolutely, the different approaches to faith and tradition by the Amish and Mennonites provide valuable insights into the multifaceted nature of religious beliefs.

    2. The diversity of practices within Christianity is truly fascinating. It’s a reminder of the complexity and depth of religious traditions.

  4. The differences in the usage of technology between Amish and Mennonites show how faith can shape everyday life. It’s thought-provoking to consider this intersection.

    1. Definitely, it’s fascinating to see how their religious beliefs translate into their practical choices in the modern world.

  5. The commitment to humility and simplicity in the Amish way of life is truly remarkable. It’s a valuable example of living with purpose and conviction.

  6. The Mennonites’ emphasis on missionary work and outreach efforts reflects a deep commitment to their faith. It’s an inspiring aspect of their religious practice.

  7. The dedication of Amish and Mennonites to their religious practices is impressive. It’s a testament to the strength of their faith and tradition.

    1. Their unwavering dedication to their religious values is truly commendable. It’s a reflection of their deep convictions.

  8. The strict adherence to traditional values and separation from modern society by the Amish is quite extreme, but it’s a unique way of life that deserves to be understood rather than judged.

    1. I agree, their commitment to their beliefs is commendable, even if it’s different from mainstream society.

  9. Avatar of Olivia Walker
    Olivia Walker

    The Mennonites’ approach of embracing modernity while maintaining core values is intriguing. It’s a good example of finding a balance between tradition and progress.

  10. Avatar of Martin Suzanne
    Martin Suzanne

    The contrast between Amish and Mennonite beliefs highlights the nuances within Christianity. It’s a reminder that religious traditions can vary widely.

    1. Absolutely, it’s important to recognize the diversity within Christianity and understand different interpretations and practices.

    2. Avatar of Theresa Robertson
      Theresa Robertson

      The unique practices of the Amish and Mennonites bring depth to the study of religious traditions. It’s enlightening to learn about their beliefs.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Want to save this article for later? Click the heart in the bottom right corner to save to your own articles box!