Minority groups like Amish and Jewish share many similarities in terms of their ideological origins and political turbulence in Europe.
Both the Amish and Jewish inhabited the borderline of European society. As a result, they have some similarities.
The most significant similarity is that both groups are genetically and socially closed societies. They have differences, too, that make them distinct from each other.
Key Takeaways
- The Amish are a Christian religious group known for their simple way of life, while Jewish people are followers of the Jewish faith and culture.
- The Amish live in rural communities and practice a traditional agrarian lifestyle. At the same time, Jewish people can be found in communities worldwide and engage in a wide range of professions and lifestyles.
- The Amish avoid modern technology and cultural influences, while Jewish people embrace modernity and a diversity of cultural influences.
Amish vs Jewish
The difference between Amish and Jewish is that Amish are the newer group compared to the Jewish. The Amish group was formed in the latter half of the seventeenth century (1693). On the other hand, the Jewish group was formed around two thousand B.C. Amish people live their life following the Ordnung. While Jewish people live their life following Ten and Torah commandments.
The Amish group is traditionalist Christian church followers with Alsatian Anabaptist and Swiss German origins. Amish are related to Mennonite churches.
They are known for their simple dressing, simple living, lack of modern technology adoption, and Christian pacifism. They value manual labour, rural life, and humanity.
They live their life following Ordnung, which is a set of rules about interactions with outsiders, dress, religious duties, limited use of technology, and so on.
Jewish are part of the ethnoreligious group. They originated from Hebrews (Judah) and Israel. The term ‘Jew’ came from the Roman word ‘Judean’, a person from the Southern kingdom of Judah.
Jewish people and their religion, nationhood, and ethnicity are very closely interrelated, as the religion of Judaism is the ethnic religion of the Jewish group.
Comparison Table
| Parameters of Comparison | Amish | Jewish |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Amish or Amish Mennonites are a Christian group in North America. The group was formed in the latter half of the seventeenth century (1693). | Jewish group was formed around two thousand B.C. They are part of the ethnoreligious group. They originated from Hebrews (Judah) and Israel. |
| Standard of living | Amish people follow Ordnung, a set of rules about interactions with outsiders, dress, religious duties, limited use of technology, and so on. | Jewish people live their life following Ten and Torah commandments. |
| Concept of Afterlife | Amish people believe that a person goes to hell or heaven based on their actions. They don’t have a concept of the afterlife. | Jewish people don’t have a common concept of the afterlife. They believe that the word will be changed to its original state. |
| Language | Amish people use Pennsylvania Dutch in Lancaster Country. | Jewish people use the Hebrew language. |
| Followers | Amish groups have a limited number of followers as it is a newer religious group compared to the Jewish group. | Jewish have a large number of followers who contribute and influence human progress in many fields like science and technology, music, politics, ethics, business, fine arts, architecture, and so on. |
What is Amish?
Amish or Amish Mennonite people are a Christian group in North America. The Amish group was formed in the latter half of the seventeenth century (1693).
Amish culture is based on the concept of community, family, humanity, and disconnection from the world.
Amish people follow Ordnung, a set of rules about interactions with outsiders, dress, religious duties, limited use of technology, and so on.
Amish people believe that a person goes to hell or heaven based on their actions. They don’t have a concept of the afterlife.
Amish people are known for their simple clothing, especially hand-made clothing. Boys and men wear dark-coloured suits, black hats, black socks, and straight-cut coats with broad fall pants.
Amish men grow beards but are forbidden to grow moustaches after marriage. Amish girls and women wear full-length dresses, shawls, and aprons.
Amish women don’t cut their hair and are not allowed to wear any jewellery.
Amish people are skilled in farming, growing and storing most of their stores. The old order of the Amish group doesn’t use modern farm machinery.
As a result, farming involves many people, both men and women. They prefer hard work over using modern advanced technologies.
Technological advancement is undesirable among Amish people as these technologies decrease the need for hard work.
What is Jewish?
The term ‘Jew’ came from the Roman word ‘Judean’, a person from the Southern kingdom of Judah.
Jewish are part of the ethnoreligious group. They originated from Hebrews (Judah) and Israel. Jewish group was formed around two thousand B.C. They are part of the ethnoreligious group.
Jewish foods, customs, costumes, culture, and music reflect the places Jewish have inhabited earlier, whether it was in Asia, Europe, Africa, or the Middle East.
European Jews are known as Ashkenazim. Jews from Portugal and Spain are known as Sephardim. On the other hand, Jews from North Africa and the Middle East are known as Mizrachim.
Jewish people live their life following Ten and Torah commandments. Jewish people don’t have a common concept of the afterlife.
They believe that the word will be changed to its original state. Jewish people use the Hebrew language.
Jewish people contribute to and influence human progress in many fields like science and technology, music, politics, ethics, business, fine arts, architecture, and so on.
Any governing body or authority does not govern the Jewish community. Several religious and secular institutions at the international, national, and local levels lead different parts of the Jewish community.
Jewish people use the Hebrew language.
Main Differences Between Amish and Jewish
- Amish or Amish Mennonites are a Christian group in North America. The group was formed in the latter half of the seventeenth century (1693). On the other hand, the Jewish group was formed around two thousand B.C.
- They are part of the ethnoreligious group. They originated from Hebrews (Judah) and Israel.
- Amish people follow Ordnung, a set of rules about interactions with outsiders, dress, religious duties, limited use of technology, and so on. While Jewish people live their life following Ten and Torah commandments.
- Amish people believe that a person goes to hell or heaven based on their actions. They don’t have a concept of the afterlife. On the contrary, Jewish people don’t have a common concept of the afterlife. They believe that the word will be changed to its original state.
- Amish people use Pennsylvania Dutch in Lancaster Country. Jewish people use the Hebrew language.
- Amish groups have a limited number of followers as it is a newer religious group compared to the Jewish group. Jewish have a large number of followers who contribute to and influence human progress in many fields like science and technology, music, politics, ethics, business, fine arts, architecture, and so on.
- https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=qUiJCwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PT6&dq=who+are+amish+people&ots=SWNXRVIE3D&sig=MMGtTe-HGHL-bJESQotaKjE8ZTk&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=who%20are%20amish%20people&f=false
- https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=Y1j6DwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR9&dq=who+are+Jewish+people&ots=7jX5r402p0&sig=1hwoQsWZsks8pqvf989vgZHOhe8&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=who%20are%20Jewish%20people&f=false
Last Updated : 13 July, 2023
I’ve put so much effort writing this blog post to provide value to you. It’ll be very helpful for me, if you consider sharing it on social media or with your friends/family. SHARING IS ♥️
Chara Yadav holds MBA in Finance. Her goal is to simplify finance-related topics. She has worked in finance for about 25 years. She has held multiple finance and banking classes for business schools and communities. Read more at her bio page.
It’s interesting to note the differences in the origin and formation of the Amish and Jewish communities, shedding light on their distinct historical timelines.
The article provides a comprehensive understanding of the Amish and Jewish communities, shedding light on their origins, customs, and societal structures.
The detailed descriptions of the Amish and Jewish cultures reveal the unique traditions, values, and societal norms that distinguish these two communities.
The article offers a nuanced examination of the Amish and Jewish communities, highlighting their contrasting approaches to language, lifestyle, and religious beliefs.
The comparative analysis of the Amish and Jewish groups effectively showcases the historical, religious, and social differences that contribute to their distinct identities.
The article presents a comprehensive exploration of the Amish and Jewish communities, elucidating the multifaceted aspects of their religious, social, and cultural traditions.
The detailed comparison table is very informative, providing a clear overview of the differences in the beliefs, lifestyles, and language of the Amish and Jewish people.
The distinction between the Amish and Jewish groups is well articulated, showcasing their contrasting approaches to technology, language, and followers.
The article effectively captures the unique aspects of the Amish and Jewish communities, offering valuable insights into their cultural and religious practices.
The article provides an insightful comparison between the Amish and Jewish communities, focusing on their origins, lifestyles, and religious beliefs.
The comprehensive overview of the Amish and Jewish communities provides valuable insights into their cultural, religious, and societal distinctions, enriching our understanding of these minority groups.
The comparative study of the Amish and Jewish groups offers a sophisticated analysis of their historical, religious, and social dynamics, fostering a deeper appreciation of their distinct heritage.
The article effectively delineates the key differences between the Amish and Jewish communities, emphasizing their divergent origins and cultural practices.
The in-depth analysis of the beliefs and way of life of both the Amish and Jewish communities highlights the complexity and diversity within each group.
The article offers a compelling comparison of the Amish and Jewish communities, emphasizing their cultural and religious differences while acknowledging their shared historical experiences.