Difference Between Hard Water and Soft Water (With Table)

 Water is an essential compound for the survival of all living organisms. Moreover, the major part of the earth and all the living organisms on earth is made up of water. The water is a tasteless, odorless, colorless liquid and an excellent solvent.

The two dissimilar classifications are Hard Water and Soft Water. Both Hard water and Soft water are not differentiable with five senses, but they are extremely different from each other.

Hard Water vs Soft Water

The difference between Hard Water and Soft Water is that Hard Water is generally known for the existence of salts such as calcium and magnesium, whereas Soft Water is known for the non-existence of water-soluble salts such as calcium and magnesium. Hard Water, instead of forming bubbles or froth with soap easily, forms an insoluble precipitate with soap, whereas Soft Water can form lather with the soap easily.

Hard water is an excellent solvent of mineral salts, ions, and molecules. When it reaches the ground surface of the earth, it dissolves many salts such as calcium and magnesium salts through rain and air. Thus the presence of these salts makes the pure water ‘Hard.’ The Hard Water, instead of forming lather with soap easily, forms an insoluble precipitate with soap.

Soft Water contains a very less concentration of only a few soluble salts such as calcium and magnesium salts. Soft water is treated with water containing sodium cation ions. Soft Water produces sufficient lather with soap easily does not form an insoluble scum with soap. Thus it can be used for cleaning purposes.

Comparison Table Between Hard Water and Soft Water

Parameters of Comparison Hard Water Soft Water
DefinitionThe mineral salts such as calcium and magnesium in the sort of chlorides, and sulfates are present. The soluble salts of calcium and magnesium are not present.
ComponentsIt contains calcium and magnesium ions.It contains sodium ions
Reaction with soap        It does not form any bubbles or froth with soap. It naturally lathers with soap easily.
TasteHard Water is tasteless. Soft Water is often salty.
Effectiveness on CleaningHard Water is not effective for cleaning purposes.          Soft Water is effective for cleaning purposes.
ExamplesGroundwater.    Rainwater.

What is Hard Water?

Soluble salts such as magnesium and calcium in the water are responsible for the formation of Hard Water that does not form any bubbles or froth with soap easily. The existence of sodium in soap can start the reaction with Hard Water to scum out calcium or magnesium stearate. Thus it is not suitable for laundry and is harmful to boilers.

Temporary Hard Water occurs due to the existence of magnesium and calcium hydrogen carbonates in the water. During boiling, magnesium bicarbonate is converted into magnesium hydroxide, and the precipitates obtained are removed through filtration. As a result, Soft Water is formed.

In Clark’s process, a calculated quantity of lime is added to Hard Water. Therefore calcium carbonate is precipitated out, and Magnesium hydroxide is filtered. As a result, soft water is obtained. Soluble salts such as magnesium and calcium in the water are responsible for the formation of Permanent Hard Water. These salts contain various chlorides and sulfates in water.

Permanent Hardness in the water is often removed by clarifying the water with washing soda, Calgon’s method, and the Ion-exchange method.

What is Soft Water?

Soft Water consists only of very low concentrations of any mineral salts, or it doesn’t have any existence of soluble salts such as calcium and magnesium salts. Soft Water comprises Sodium cation ions. Soft Water lathers with soap easily. Thus it is suitable for cleaning purposes. It does not stain clothes rather makes them brighter and sparkling.

Soft Water is not used for drinking due to its high Sodium and salty taste. Soft Water is treated water obtained from hard water that can be used for bathing because it’s beneficial for hair and skin.

Soft Water is suitable to use in washing machines, dishwashers, coffee makers, and water heaters because it increases the lifespan of household appliances. It does not leave stains or scales on pipes, bathtubs, glasses, and plates, and it also prevents corrosion in materials.

Soft Water can cause lead poisoning if it is stored in a lead container and does not have many health benefits as there is no presence of calcium and magnesium ions. Due to no deposition of soluble salts and low boiling point, Soft Water is used in boilers. Rainwater is the perfect example of Soft Water as it is almost pure and later easily with soap.

Main Differences Between Hard Water and Soft Water

  1. Hard Water is generally known for the existence of salts such as calcium and magnesium, whereas Soft Water does not have any existence of these soluble salts of calcium and magnesium and only contains Sodium cation ions.
  2. Hard Water does not form any bubbles or froth with soap, whereas Soft does create bubbles or froth with soap easily.
  3. Hard Water is not used for cleaning purposes, whereas Soft Water is used for cleaning purposes.
  4. Hard Water can be used for drinking purposes, whereas Soft Water is not recommended for drinking purposes.
  5. Hard Water is tasteless, whereas Soft Water has a salt taste.

Conclusion

Water has great importance due to its ability to dissolve many substances. The two dissimilar classifications are Hard Water and Soft Water. The water that can easily form lathers with soap and has does not water-soluble salts is known as Soft Water, and the water that does not create any lather easily with a soap solution. Instead, it tends to produce an insoluble white precipitate. The water is called Hard Water.

Soft Water can be obtained from Hard Water by water-softener methods. Both Hard Water and Soft Water are indistinguishable from each other, yet they are extremely different in mineral contents and many more. Although Hard Water and Soft Water have many advantages like any other chemical substances, it has hardly any disadvantages.

References

  1. https://www.bmj.com/content/2/5857/21.abstract
  2. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0043135476901287
x
2D vs 3D