New York Strip vs Ribeye: Difference and Comparison

Eating a perfect steak is everybody’s dream. For that, we have to check the steak’s quality before buying them in the market. Two popular steaks that many people prefer are New York Strip and the other one is Ribeye.

Also, these two steaks got many different names and were sometimes served as a signature dish in some restaurants in earlier days. 

Key Takeaways

  1. New York Strip is a leaner cut of beef from the short loin, while Ribeye is a fattier cut from the rib section.
  2. New York Strip has a firmer texture and a less pronounced flavor than Ribeye, which has a rich, beefy flavor and a tender texture.
  3. Due to its lower fat content, New York Strip is less expensive than Ribeye.

New York Strip vs Ribeye

New York strip is beef steak rich in tenderness. It contains less fats. People prefer this steak because of its chewiness and flavor but it is expensive. It is not healthy as compared to other healthier options. Ribeye is a cow steak that has a juicy flavor. Bones are removed from this steak. Overcooking this steak can ruin its taste.

New York Strip vs Ribeye
/10

Food Quiz

Test your knowledge about topics related to food

1 / 10

What type of sweet dish is typically served after the main course of a meal to complete the dining experience?

2 / 10

Which of these is added to the food label because people sometimes don't eat ENOUGH of this?

3 / 10

"Fish and chips" is the national dish of which country?

4 / 10

How many teaspoons in 1 tablespoon?

5 / 10

Which type of pizza is topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and other toppings of your choice?

6 / 10

A person suffering from high blood pressure should avoid foods which are rich in

7 / 10

What is the traditional frosting for carrot cake?

8 / 10

Rockmelons are an excellent source of which vitamin, which can also be found in oranges?

9 / 10

I am linked to the story of Adam and Eve, even mentioned when people are studying Newton. Guess what fruit am I?

10 / 10

What type of oven is best for making cakes and baked goods?

Your score is

0%

Many people consider the New York strip because of its tenderness and flavour. It also got a competitor called Sirloin, which is cut from New York Strip.

Many people love sirloin also because of its tenderness, which makes them juicier and richer. This strip comes only from the cow. Before buying them, you should check out the steak so that when you cook, it will give a good taste. 

Ribeye is a slice of meat preferred by people for its juicy flavours. It is also a substitute when it comes to healthy options because it is high in fat, which will not be healthy for some people.

People who are having risk from eating high fats should avoid eating this steak. If you want a tasty and enjoyable meal in a day, you can go for it. 

Comparison Table

Parameters of ComparisonNew York StripRibeye
Also calledHotel cut steakBeauty steak
PropertiesIn this steak, fat will be settled downIf you properly cook this steak, it will melt in your mouth
Tips for BuyingIf the cuts are even in the steak, then you can buy themIf the steaks are thick by at least 1 inch, you can buy them
TextureThe New York strip has a very high textureRibeye does not have a high texture
TendernessThe New York strip will be more tender and richerRibeye does not have much tenderness

What is New York Strip?

The New York strip comes from beef steaks. People in the United States of America used to call this as New York Strip instead of calling them steaks. It also has another name, called club steak.

In cows, the top part behind the ribs is used for making New York strips. It is also called the Longissimus muscle. This muscle is used to make the steak more tender because it has worked a lot.

It has some fat at the edge of the steak as well. If you are thinking of something equivalent to the New York strip, then you can consider the option of Sirloin. It comes from the UK, and many people there used to eat this.

It got this name because of its association with the city. In 1827, it was also offered as a signature dish in many New York restaurants, and that is how it became more famous. It has bold and intense flavours, making the steak taste better.

People love this steak because when they bite them, they love it for its solid chewiness. It will create a robust flavour and also makes a good-tasting experience.

But people in the UK used to prefer Sirloin to the New York strip because it is even more tender and juicy. The New York strip has got more marbling, and this reason makes it more expensive as well.

But when you consider the healthier options, it is not that healthy. If you want to have something healthy and don’t want the taste to get ruined, then you can prefer filet mignon.

new york strip

What is Ribeye?

Ribeye is a steak cut from the ribs’ outer side. If you want some ultimate juicy and beefy flavour, then you can go for ribeye without any second thought. It comes from the cow’s upper rib area.

They are flat, which helps them retain their juicy flavour whenever they are cooked on high heat. Since this type of steak is found in the cow’s centremost part, it has its name ribeye.

In this steak, the bone will also be removed. People who are interested in eating boneless steaks will prefer them. But this steak is expensive because it is cut from the most desirable part, making it more expensive.

If you want a good meal to eat during your day, then rib eye is one of the best options for you. Many people consider this steak because it is highly marbled, which you can’t find in some other steaks.

But this has got more fat than other steaks, which makes it unhealthy.

If you want something healthier and at the same time don’t want to compensate for the taste, then you can go for New York Strip. Because it has got less fat when compared to ribeye steak.

To get a proper taste, you must ensure you cook the meat properly. Otherwise, it will become more like rubber in taste when you overcook it. Taking some additional tips from a professional person will help you in achieving it.

ribeye

Main Differences Between New York Strip and Ribeye

  1. New York Strip is also called hotel cut steak. On the other hand, Ribeye is also called beauty steak.
  2. In New York Strip, the fats will be settled under the steak. On the other hand, if you cook ribeye, then it will melt in your mouth.
  3. If you find the New York Strip steak even, you can definitely buy them. On the other hand, if the ribeye steaks are at least 1 inch, then you can buy them.
  4. New York Strip steak has got a very high texture. On the other hand, Ribeye has got very less texture.
  5. New York Strip has a good tenderness and rich taste. On the other hand, Ribeye has got juicier flavour and less tenderness. 
Difference Between New York Strip and Ribeye
References
  1. https://academic.oup.com/jas/article-abstract/69/8/3274/4704987
  2. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1745-4557.1989.tb00328.x

Last Updated : 11 June, 2023

dot 1
One request?

I’ve put so much effort writing this blog post to provide value to you. It’ll be very helpful for me, if you consider sharing it on social media or with your friends/family. SHARING IS ♥️

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Want to save this article for later? Click the heart in the bottom right corner to save to your own articles box!