Difference Between Indian Music Notes and Western Music Notes (With Table)

A musical note is a concept that describes the pitch and period of a sound. It shows whether a sound is high or low. Instead of identifying the sounds by their frequency, musicians gave them letter names. Different regions have their naming convention for music notes. The solfege system is used in countries like Italy, Spain, Greece, France, Portugal, and so on. The Indian tradition has the Swara system.  

Indian Music Notes vs Western Music Notes

The difference between Indian music notes and western music notes is that they are from vastly contrasting cultures. While traditional classical Indian music is rooted in spirituality and human connection, western music does not have such relations. It is all about the notations and what is written.

Indian music notes are a culmination of the contributions from various cultures in the diverse land of India. Raga and tala are the foundation of this musical tradition. The two traditions from the south and the north have slight variations in their scales and articulation. The saptaka denotes the notes in Indian music, and it has subdivisions called shruti. There is no standardized notation for Indian music notes.

Western music has its origins in Europe. There is a standardized system of notations for western music notes. This maintains uniformity and rigidity. The music is played by following the notations. The harmony in this music tradition is made up of groups of notes played continuously. There are two sets of pitch ratios. The octave note system is followed. Like Indian music notes, western music notes also have sharp notes and flat notes. 

Comparison Table Between Indian Music Notes and Western Music Notes

Parameters of ComparisonIndian Music NotesWestern Music Notes
OriginIndiaWestern countries
BasisMelodyHarmony
Scales usedParent scale and descendant scaleMajor and minor scale
SpiritualityPresentAbsent
Scope for improvisationPresentAbsent

What are Indian Music Notes?

There are two major music traditions in India; The Hindustani and The Carnatic. The Indian music notes consist of seven notes. They are collectively called Swara. The notes are sa, re, ga, ma, pa, dha, and ni. This system of sapta Swara is called Sargam.

 These notes have their specific names; Sadja for sa, Risabh for re, Gandhara for ga, Madhyama for ma, Panchama for pa, Dhaivata for dha, and Nishada for ni. The unalterable Swara, sa, and pa are achal swaras, and the other swaras are chal swaras as they move from their initial positions. There are twelve semitones in the Indian music scale, and it is again divided into 22 notes called shruti.

The basis of Indian music is the use of intonation and gliding between notes. Natural notes are called shuddha. Flat notes are Komal Swar, and sharp notes are Tivra swar. The notes have an association with animal sounds as well. The note Sa is derived from peacock, Re from the bull, Ga from goat, Ma from heron, Pa from cuckoo, Dha from the horse, and Ni from the elephant. The swaras are also associated with planets, colors, and chakras in the body.

What are Western Music Notes?

Western music originated from western civilization. There are twelve notes in western music, which is called the octave. Western music has a solid notation scheme. The harmony in western music is created out of twelve notes. C, D, E, F, G, A, and B are the notes with five flats and sharps. 

All the western musical instruments have the chromatic scale system. The order is that of ascending fashion. It is a set of pitch classes that has notes and is separated with semitones. The notation system was first used by Boethius. He used Latin alphabets. Today, the Helmholtz pitch notation system and the scientific notation system are in use. 

The tuning system is centered around the pleasing octave, perfect fourth, and perfect fifth intervals. The microtonal music goes beyond the twelve notes. The archetypical notation system is followed by everyone who plays western music.

The musical traditions evolved from the Baroque period, the romantic period, and the music traditions of Europe. The notation system is designed to enhance the system for playing, composing, and recording as well as improving the effects on listeners.

Main Differences Between Indian Music Notes and Western Music Notes

  1. Indian music stems from the melody that is a tune soothing and content to the ear. It is derived from the ragas. There are hundreds of ragas, and they are the frameworks upon which artists create music. On the other hand, western music is based on harmony, and it has a lot of layers.
  2. There is a scope for improvisation in Indian music notes as it is not written and rigid. While in western music, the notes are written on a staff, and it is played according to what is written.
  3. Indian classical music notes are related to spirituality and nature. The notes are derived from animal sounds and are related to planets and chakras. But in western music notes, such a sense is absent.
  4. There are two traditions for Indian music notes, the North Indian style called Hindustani and the South Indian style called Carnatic. Western music notes explore European life and related cultures.
  5. The melodies in Indian music are played in a specific order or framework. But western harmony uses tonic progression and counterpoint.
  6. There are major and minor scales in western music. In Indian music notes, there is a complex system of scales with parent scales and descendant scales.

Conclusion

Unlike the natives, foreign people find it hard to learn the music notations, be it western or Indian. The key is to understand that western notes are absolute, but Indian music notes are relative. The western musicians follow the same notations as the staff. There is less room for changing styles. The versatility of western music notations enables learners to advance in their musical journey as it is universal, and anyone can play any music following the notations. The warmth and pleasant quality of Indian music are also notable.

References

  1. hhttps://www.researchgate.net/profile/Kk-Achary/publication/228885219_Raga_Mining_of_Indian_Music_by_Extracting_Arohana-Avarohana_Pattern/links/00b7d515fef5a2d952000000/Raga-Mining-of-Indian-Music-by-Extracting-Arohana-Avarohana-Pattern.pdf
  2. https://archives.ismir.net/ismir2013/paper/000027.pdf

x
2D vs 3D