Stationary vs Non-Stationary Signals: Difference and Comparison

Signals are measurable quantities in a physical system that are produced within the system. These can be represented in the form of digitally obtained graphs.

The classification of signals can be done under various lenses. It could be done in terms of continuity (Continuous vs discrete), periodicity (Periodic vs Aperiodic), probability (Deterministic versus random), stationarity (stationary versus non-stationary) etc.

Key Takeaways

  1. Stationary signals have statistical properties that do not change over time, while non-stationary signals’ properties do change.
  2. Stationary signals are more predictable and easier to analyze, while non-stationary signals require advanced analysis methods.
  3. Stationary signals are suitable for linear time-invariant systems, whereas non-stationary signals are more common in real-world applications.

Stationary vs Non-Stationary Signals

The difference between stationary and non-stationary signals is that the properties of a static process signal do not change with time. In contrast, a Non-stationary signal is a process inconsistent with time.

Stationary vs Non stationary signals

Speech can be considered to be a form of non-stationary signal. Other synthetic forms of signs are triangular, wave etc.


 

Comparison Table

Parameter of ComparisonStationary SignalsNon-Stationary
TimeThe period for the static signal remains constant at all times.The period for a non-stationary signal varies with time and is not constant.
FrequencyThe frequency of a stationary signal remains constant across the processThe frequency of a Non-stationary wave constantly changes during the process.
Spectral ContentsSpectral content for Stationary signals is constantSpectral ranges are dynamic and keep changing in case of non-stationary calls.
Fourier EquationFourier transform is good at representing stationary signalsFourier transform is non-good at representing non-stationary signals.
ExamplesSingle-tone sinewave constant frequency, Multitone sine wave of constant frequencySpeech signals, Multitone sinewave of varied frequency

 

What are Stationary Signals?

A stationary signal is a wave generated by keeping the period and spectral content value constant. A fixed signal can be generated via a software or function generator as a sine wave.

Also Read:  P N Junction Diode vs Zener Diode: Difference and Comparison

Stationarity explains the behaviour of a signal wave in terms of its frequency and time relation. Here, if the frequency of the sine wave is changed, a completely new wave is devised; hence it will not remain stationary anymore.

Both singleton and multitone constant frequency sine waves are hence examples of stationary signals. Both can be represented through two different equations.

Other examples of Stationary Signals are;

  1. White Noise– In the case of white noise, any signal value is equally probable concerning any other signal value at spaced-out reference points.
  2. Temperature– it can be considered a stationary single for a short time.
stationary signals 1
 

What are Non-Stationary Signals?

A non-stationary signal is when the fundamental assumptions defining a stationary call are no longer valid.

The sine wave representation of a non-stationary equation is hence constantly changing. The spectral contents for such signals are also not constant.

Firstly, speech signals may have multiple frequency components within a given interval of time.

Secondly, the interval itself may be extremely short lesser than 10-30msec as compared to 250msec.

Therefore, in a speech signal, there would be multiple sets of frequency contents, which are likely to change dynamically concerning time.

non stationary signals

Main Differences Between Stationary and Non-Stationary Signals

  1. The Fourier transform gives good results for stationary signals, while It is not a good representation for non-stationary signals.
  2. Examples of stationary signals include white noise, single-tone sine-wave with constant frequency and multitone sinewave with a constant frequency. In contrast, Non-stationary signal examples include Speech signals and multitone sine waves with varied frequencies.

References
  1. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0888327004001517
  2. https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/abs/10.1098/rspa.2006.1761
Also Read:  Cockroach vs Beetle: Difference and Comparison

Last Updated : 11 June, 2023

dot 1
One request?

I’ve put so much effort writing this blog post to provide value to you. It’ll be very helpful for me, if you consider sharing it on social media or with your friends/family. SHARING IS ♥️

23 thoughts on “Stationary vs Non-Stationary Signals: Difference and Comparison”

  1. This scientific explanation with multi-lens approach is a masterpiece. It provides the perfect solid basis for any understanding of physical systems signals.

    Reply
  2. The comparison table is the most useful part. It helped me understand the concept with clarity. I believe that this approach suits a broader audience.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Want to save this article for later? Click the heart in the bottom right corner to save to your own articles box!