Difference Between Echo Dot and Google Mini (With Table)

Smart speakers are not only a trend and craze of the moment but are increasingly becoming a necessity as our lives become faster and advanced. Smart speakers today not only help us listen to our music on demand but can also schedule our days, make lists, and also control smart devices in pairs turning our life s and homes into smart lives and smart homes.

Echo Dot vs Google Mini

The difference between Echo Dot and Google Mini lies primarily in their type of assistants. Owning to different assistants, their ease of functionality and added features also differ from each other. Echo Dot uses the Amazon Assistant, Alexa for its functions, while Google Mini accommodates the Google Assistant.

The Echo Dot is an Amazon launched smart wireless speaker that can be used to listen to music, hear podcasts, set timers, make lists, search general queries from the internet and much more on voice command. It even responds to your questions and can monitor other smart devices in the home connected to it.

The Google Mini is a Google Launched smart wireless speaker that can be used to do all the functions as stated above. It can stream online videos and music, play songs, place calls, set reminders, influence other smart devices, search recipes and answer questions from the internet and so on, on voice command.

Comparison Table Between Echo Dot and Google Mini

Parameters of ComparisonEcho DotGoogle Mini
AppearanceIt appears like an ice hockey pug with rounded edges and flat faces. (1st generation and 2nd generation models) . It has a metallic surface with speakers on the periphery.It has a similar shape to the Echo Dot but its faces are also rounded and covered by fabric and plastic meshes giving it a more velvety appearance.
WeightIt weighs around 0.25 kg.It weighs around 0.17 kg
MicrophonesIt has four microphones to receive sound on its exposed upper face.Its microphones are covered by the meshes.
SwitchesThe Amazon Echo Dot has four control switches on the top of the device.It does not have any designated buttons on its surface except the mute button .
LightingIt has indicator lights: ring lights with various colours like yellow, green, blue and red and white.It has four dots on its surface with led lights with indicators of fewer colours like yellow, red and green and white
Mute SwitchThe mute button lies on the top of the deviceMute button present on the underside of the device.
Connectivity to other SpeakersIt has provisions to connect to other speakers with a 3.5 mm jack.It does not have any such options.
Wall MountingNo option for wall mounting.Has a provision of wall hanging from a hook.
Music StreamingCan stream online music from multiple platforms like Spotify, Amazon Music, etc.Can stream music from additional sites like YouTube music.
Services ProvidedServices provided are mostly Amazon centric.Services are broader as Google has more services.
Smart AssistantAmazon Smart Assistant AlexaUtilizes Google Smart Assistant

What is Echo Dot?

The Echo Dot is a smart speaker launched by Amazon. It has four generations of updates also available in the market, some of them being Echo Clock and Echo Kids. It is a smart wireless speaker with Wi-Fi connectivity requires to function. It has an integrated Smart Assistant – Alexa who runs on voice commands.

It can perform functions like play and stream online and offline music from the internet or your phone, search general queries, set reminders, make to-do lists, set times, learn recipes and operate other smart appliances with the help of its interactive two-way audio. There is no camera or video provisions.

It has a rich sound coming from its peripheral speakers. Their naked microphones on top and designated buttons on the top make it easier to use. It is very easy to set up. You can change your phrase of activation of the device using its mobile app. It also has indicator lights of the colour green for calls, yellow for mute, red for problem shooting or switched off, white for switch on, blue for when Alexa is listening. This makes the device very interactive as well.

You can connect this speaker to other speakers using a 3.5 mm jack to turn other speakers into one integrated system. The only drawback to these speakers is that their services and streaming platforms are limited. Being Amazon launched, it usually focuses on Amazon services more. Also, it is not the ideal device to search or ask questions from the internet as it is known as a smart speaker, not a searching assistant.

We found the best deal(s) on Amazon for you

# Preview Product
1 Echo Dot (3rd Gen) - Smart... Echo Dot (3rd Gen) - Smart speaker with Alexa - Charcoal

What is Google Mini?

The Google Mini is a smart speaker launched by Google. It has two generations of updates available in the market. It is a smart wireless speaker that works with Wi-Fi connectivity and a smartphone App. It has integrated Smart Assistant – Google Assistant who runs on voice commands.

It can perform similar functions like play and stream online and offline music from the internet or your phone, search general queries, set reminders, make to-do lists, set times, learn recipes and operate other smart appliances with the help of its interactive two way audio like the Echo device. There is no camera or video provisions just like the former.

It also has clear, rich sounds with a slightly darker bass than the other. Their microphone s although covered, have good exposure to sound. Devoid of buttons, they have sensitive areas on the upper surface of the speaker for volume up and down, pause and start and to speak with Google Assistant. Their indicator lights also have the colour green for calls, red for mute or switched off or problem shooting and white for interaction with Assistant.

You cannot connect other speakers to it to make them as one smart unit. Unless the other speaker is compatible with Google assistant, it cannot function together. It’s plus point lies in the wide variety of services it provides across all Google support platforms. Also, it can provide were detailed answers to questions from Google itself.

We found the best deal(s) on Amazon for you

# Preview Product
1 Outlet Wall Mount Holder for... Outlet Wall Mount Holder for Google Nest Mini and Google Home Mini, A Space-Saving Accessories with...

Main Differences Between Echo Dot and Google Mini

  1. Echo mini has rich, clear ringing sounds from speakers at its periphery. Google Mini has speakers all around its surface.
  2. The mute button lies on the upper face of the Echo Dot while it is present on the lower surface of the Google Mini Devices.
  3. You cannot stream music from YouTube Music in Echo dot, whereas it can be accessed by Google Mini.
  4. The smart assistant in Echo Dot is Amazon Assistant Alexa, while the smart assistant in Google Mini is Google Assistant.
  5. Echo Dot is easier to use due to buttons on its surface, whereas the Google Mini has a more minimalist look without buttons.
  6. Echo dot has a 3.5 mm jack aperture, whereas it is absent in Google Mini.
  7. Echo Dot cannot access directions as it does not support Google Maps, which is supported by the Google Mini smart speaker.

Conclusion

As our homes are slowly transforming into smart homes with smart appliances like light bulbs, plugs, air conditioner kettles, fans and so on. It almost becomes necessary to have a smart assistant to help you control them. Apart from helping with everyday chores, Smart assistants also help by answering questions that you would normally have to type.

 Both Echo Dot and Google Mini are budget-friendly smart devices that effectively achieve these functions. Their services are also comparable but the main difference between buyers being their Smart Assistant preference. Echo Dot has Alexa, and Google Mini has Google Assistant, and both are equally responsible if audible and properly spoken to.

References

  1. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-68285-9_29
  2. https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.04574

Last update on 2021-10-22 / Amazon Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

x
2D vs 3D