Lewis Acid vs Base: Difference and Comparison

Chemistry would be incomplete without interaction between Lewis Acids and Lewis Bases. The Brønsted-Lowry acid theory has shaped chemistry.

G.N. Lewis, in 1923, suggested that there is a transfer of electrons and not protons. This theory helped chemists forecast a broader range of reactions between Acids and Bases.

Key Takeaways

  1. Lewis acid is a substance that can accept a pair of electrons, while Lewis base is a substance that can donate a pair of electrons.
  2. Lewis acid and a base react to form a coordinated covalent bond.
  3. Lewis acid and base play an important role in chemical reactions such as acid-base reactions and catalysis.

Lewis Acid vs Base

A Lewis acid is a chemical species that can accept a pair of electrons, having an electron-deficient atom during a chemical reaction. A Lewis base is a chemical species that can donate a pair of electrons during a chemical reaction and is a substance that has an electron-rich atom.

Lewis Acid vs Base

Lewis Acid has empty shells, and they are labelled as electrophiles. It is a species lured to an electron-rich core. Lewis Acids have lower energy as they have empty shells.

Mostly all of the cations are part of the Lewis Acid species. If a molecule, ion, or atom happens to have a deficient set of octet electrons, they behave as a Lewis Acid.

Lewis Base has abundant shells, and they exist labelled as nucleophiles, and they have a higher energy level than Lewis’s acids. They rush at a positive charge with their lone set of an electron.

Mostly all of the anions are part of the Lewis Base species. If a molecule, atom, or ion happens to have a Lone set of an electron, they behave as Lewis Base.

Comparison Table

Parameters of ComparisonLewis AcidLewis Base
EnergyChemical species have lower energy.Chemical energy has higher energy.
IonsMostly all of the cations are part of the Lewis Acid species.Mostly all of the anions are part of the Lewis Base species.
Known termElectrophileNucleophile
FeatureShow thermodynamic features when forming adducts.Show Kinetic feature.
Electrons in the outer shellDeficient set of electrons in its outer shellsExtra set of electrons free in its outer shells.

What is a Lewis Acid?

Earlier in 1916, Lewis proposed that atoms get clenched together in a chemical frame by the distribution of electrons. According to Gilbert N. Lewis, Acid can attract an electron set from a second molecule and complete a steady form for one of its atoms.

Also Read:  Land vs Water: Difference and Comparison

A Lewis Acid is not automatically a Brønsted–Lowry acid. When a singular electron from each atom is donated, it is called a covalent bond. When one and the other electrons approach the rise of one of the atoms, it is called a coordinate bond. 

Lewis Acid gets confined to the trigonal planar classification. They are diverse and react with Lewis Base to shape adducts. Lewis Acid affirms the thermodynamic feature of adduction formation. 

Lewis Acids can get further distinguished based on hardness and softness. Hardness means they are nonpolarizable.

Based on Hardness, Acids: Boranes, alkali metal cations, H+

Based on Softness, Acids: Ni(0), Ag+

Some examples of Simple Lewis Acids:

The organoboranes and boron trihalides are a few of the Simple Lewis Acids. Illustration: BF3 + F− → BF4−

Sometimes Lewis Acid can secure two Lewis Bases:

Example: SiF4 + 2 F− → SiF62− (hexafluorosilicate)

Some examples of Complex Lewis Acids:

Sometimes some of the chemical compounds require additional activation. They need it before producing the adduct when reacting with Lewis Base. 

  1.  Usually, Monomeric BH3 does not exist and needs an activation step. The formation of Borane adducts is due to the activation step of diborane degrading. Illustration: B2H6 + 2 H− → 2 BH4− Reaction: [Mg(H2O)6]2+ + 6 NH3 → [Mg(NH3)6]2+ + 6 H2O
  2. Usually, Aluminium trihalides can not exist in the configuration of AIX3. It exists as a polymer and aggregates and degrades by Bases.

Application of Lewis Acids:

  • Friedel-Crafts alkylation 
  • Formation of carbonium ion that is tremendously electrophilic. Illustration: RCl +AlCl3 → R+ + AlCl4−

What is a Lewis Base?

Brønsted–Lowry acid-base theory states that whenever an Acid and Base respond with each other, the acid configures its conjugate base. The Base, on the other hand, interchanges a proton and configures its conjugate acid. 

The Lewis Theory has established based on the electronic structure. Lewis Base can hand out a set of electrons to H+ (proton), and its conjugate base of Brønsted–Lowry acid-base theory gets formed by losing H+.

Also Read:  Ammunition vs Munition: Difference and Comparison

So looking at Brønsted–Lowry’s acid-base theory and Lewis Theory, a Lewis base can also get classified as a Brønsted–Lowry base. 

Lewis Bases are conventional amines (ammonia), pyridine and derivatives, and alkylamines. Lewis Base has the highest occupied molecular orbit, and they affirm the kinetic feature of adduction formation.

Lewis Bases can be further distinguished based on hardness and softness. Softness means they are polarizable and larger. 

Hard Bases: Water, Chloride, Ammonia, Amines.

Soft Bases: Carbon Monoxide, Thioethers. 

Application of Lewis Bases:

Electron pair givers that shape compounds by conclusive adapting elements get viewed as Lewis Bases. They are even known as Ligands. Thus, Lewis Bases’ application lies widely in forming metal catalysts.

As Lewis Bases form many bonds with Lewis Acids, they become multidentate (chelating agents). 

Pharmaceutical companies depend on Chiral Lewis Bases, as they give out chirality on a catalyzer. This property facilitates the formation of asymmetric catalysis, which is important for producing pharmaceuticals. 

Main Differences Between Lewis Acid and Base

  1. A Lewis Acid acquires a set of electrons. Lewis Base hands out their pair of electrons.
  2. Lewis Acid has an electron-rich core. Lewis Base rush towards positive charged atoms or molecules.
  3. Lewis Acid has a deficient set of electrons in its outer shells. Lewis Base has an extra set of electrons free from the entanglement of chemical bonding. 
  4. Lewis Acid does not have the highest occupied molecular orbit. Lewis Bases molecular orbit is highly concentrated.
  5. A Lewis acid is not a Brønsted-Lowry acid. Brønsted-Lowry Base can be a Lewis Base.
References
  1. https://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/cr60311a002
  2. https://www.thieme-connect.com/products/ejournals/html/10.1055/s-2005-869831

Last Updated : 11 June, 2023

dot 1
One request?

I’ve put so much effort writing this blog post to provide value to you. It’ll be very helpful for me, if you consider sharing it on social media or with your friends/family. SHARING IS ♥️

8 thoughts on “Lewis Acid vs Base: Difference and Comparison”

  1. The detailed comparison of Lewis acid and base provided in the article is quite informative and essential for anyone studying or working in the field of chemistry.

    Reply
  2. The scientific applications of Lewis acids and bases in various chemical reactions are truly remarkable. The knowledge of these concepts opens up new possibilities for researchers and scientists.

    Reply
  3. I must say, the differentiation between Lewis acid and base presented here is quite helpful. It brings clarity to this topic and facilitates understanding.

    Reply
  4. This theory seems to be fairly complex and hard to fully grasp for the average person. It may require an extensive background in chemistry to completely understand.

    Reply
  5. This theory was a breakthrough and a great step forward in understanding chemical reactions and the behavior of acids and bases. It’s good to see how it has shaped modern chemistry.

    Reply
  6. It is fascinating to learn that Lewis acid and base played a vital role in chemical reactions like acid-base reactions and catalysis. This is important information for the world of chemistry.

    Reply
    • Especially since this theory applies to many aspects of chemicals and compounds in the world. The applications are limitless.

      Reply

Leave a Comment

Want to save this article for later? Click the heart in the bottom right corner to save to your own articles box!