Difference Between Seltzer and Club Soda (With Table)

Seltzer and Club soda refer to water that has been carbonated. Both the beverages serve as a preferred mixer option for drinks and cocktails. Usually confused to mean the same, seltzer and club soda have varying features that distinguish them from one another. The composition and taste of each drink is the prominent factor of this differentiation.

Seltzer vs Club Soda

The difference between seltzer and club soda is that seltzer tastes more or less similar to plain water. In contrast, club soda tastes a little salty or tangy. Furthermore, the seltzer contains no additives or minerals. On the other hand, club soda contains minerals such as sodium citrate, potassium bicarbonate, sodium bicarbonate, or potassium citrate. 

Seltzer refers to a bubbly beverage with no added minerals. Over the past five years, seltzer sales have soared to as high as 42 per cent. Thus, the popularity of the drink is undeniable. With a taste similar to that of plain water, seltzer contains no added sugar. As a result, it assists people to give up their sugar intake in drinks. 

Club soda is a carbonated drink with little to no sugar content. As a calorie-free drink, club soda is a viable option to cut calorie intake on drinks. Apart from quenching thirst, it provides a tiny proportion of nutrients such as calcium, iron, and zinc. With added minerals, club soda has a salty taste. 

Comparison Table Between Seltzer and Club Soda

Parameters of ComparisonSeltzerClub Soda
DefinitionSeltzer refers to carbonated water with no added minerals. Club soda refers to carbonated water added minerals. 
Other NamesSeltzer is popularly known as sparkling water.Other names of club soda are carbonated water, fizzy water, soda water, and water with gas.  
TasteThe taste of seltzer is similar to that of plain water. The taste of club soda is a bit salty and tangy due to the added minerals. 
CompositionSeltzer is devoid of any additives. Club soda mostly consists of mineral salts. 
Flavours AvailableSeltzer is available in fruity flavours.Club soda is available in simple flavours like citrus. 
Famous BrandsTruly Punch Hard Seltzer, Golden Road Fruit Cart Hard Seltzer, Michelob Ultra Organic Seltzer, and Good Company Hard Seltzer.Q Mixers Club Soda, Seagrams, Fever Tree Premium, and Canada Dry Club Soda. 

What is Seltzer?

Seltzer refers to water that has been carbonated. It is devoid of any added minerals. This, in turn, gives the drink a more water-like taste. The origin of seltzer can be traced back to Germany. Here, naturally occurring carbonated water was immensely popular. As a result, it was brought back to the United States by European immigrants. 

Seltzer usually comes with natural flavours. Usually tasting like plain water, the seltzer contains no additives at all. It is an excellent mixer as it adds effervescence to a drink without compromising on its initial flavours. Seltzer is as good a hydrating agent as water. In addition, it is far less damaging for health than regular soda. 

An individual with IBS shouldn’t drink seltzer. The carbonated drink can irritate the body and result in bloating. An advantage of seltzer is that it is relatively easy to carry. In areas where an individual is unsure about the water quality, seltzer may serve as a viable option to kill the bacteria in the mouth. 

Seltzer may increase the gas in an individual’s GI tract. The gas, in turn, may cause discomfort due to stomach cramps. A feature of Seltzer is that one can make it at home if there’s a soda maker. Conclusively, seltzer comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages as a carbonated beverage. 

What is Club Soda?

Club Soda refers to water containing dissolved CO2. Other names of club soda include carbonated water, fizzy water, soda water, and water with gas. Club soda usually contains added minerals such as sodium citrate, potassium bicarbonate, sodium bicarbonate, or potassium citrate. 

Club soda is sold in bottles and cans. William Brownrigg is thought to be the first person to aerate the water. However, it was Joseph Priestley who invented Club soda in 1767 by accident. The mass production of carbonated water began only in 1781. The first factory was set up by Thomas Henry, who was born in Manchester, England. 

Club soda has a salty taste due to the added minerals. It is usually a preferred choice of bartenders for mixed drinks. The number of minerals added to club soda are subject to the brand or manufacturer of the carbonated drink. In addition, the additive minerals enhance the flavour of the club soda. 

Club soda is a preferred mixer for cocktails. It usually offers basic flavours like citrus. In addition, club soda is simply a concentration of mineral salts. Some best-known club soda brands are Fever-Tree, Schweppes, Polar, Topo Chico, Q Spectacular, and Canada Dry. Conclusively, club soda is a widely popular carbonated drink.

Main Differences Between Seltzer and Club Soda

  1. Seltzer is commonly known as sparkling water. On the other hand, club soda is commonly known as carbonated water, fizzy water, soda water, and water with gas.
  2. The origin of seltzer can be traced back to Germany from where it was brought to the States by European Immigrants. In contrast, club soda was founded by Joseph Priestley. 
  3. While seltzer is carbonated water with no added minerals, club soda is carbonated water with added minerals. 
  4. Seltzer tastes like plain water due to the absence of additives. On the other hand, club soda gives a slightly salty taste owing to its mineral composition. 
  5. Famous brands of seltzer are Truly Punch Hard Seltzer, Golden Road Fruit Cart Hard Seltzer, Michelob Ultra Organic Seltzer, and Good Company Hard Seltzer. In contrast, famous brands of club soda are Q Mixers Club Soda, Seagrams, Fever-Tree Premium, and Canada Dry Club Soda. 

Conclusion

Although seltzer and club soda are both carbonated drinks, the two have considerable differences. Seltzer is a drink with no added minerals or additives. Club soda, however, contains added minerals that give it a slightly salty flavour. Seltzer is available in a wide array of fruity flavours. In contrast, the flavour choice of club soda is limited to a few basics. 

Both seltzer and club soda are among the favourite of mixologists and bartenders. However, club soda is a preferred mixer for cocktails. Conclusively, the mineral composition, nickname, flavour, and brand category of seltzer and club soda differentiate the two drinks. 

References

  1. http://chemrj.org/download/vol-3-iss-4-2018/chemrj-2018-03-04-176-183.pdf 
  2. https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/ed083p577 
x
2D vs 3D